SCUGSoul Coughing Underground

The 5% Nation, SCUG and Everybody Else

The Fans

Long before social media, fans kept Soul Coughing going on a newsgroup, a mailing list, an AOL board and phone lines nobody could use while you were online. This is their story. <cue Law and Order theme music>1

In the early days of the web, two sites carried most of the load. The 5% Nation started as a fan site and grew into the official one. SCUG was the side door. A newsgroup, a mailing list and an AOL board hummed along beside them. The crowds varied by town, too. In 1995 Doughty described Atlanta's as hip-hop kids, Cleveland's and Minneapolis's as indie rock types and Chicago's as bespectacled hipsters, and said he found it curious how different scenes adopted the band in different places.21

The 5% Nation

The 5% Nation came first, and it was huge. Opus Moreschi started it as a fan site, and it grew into the band's official site: where you went for news, lyrics, song notes and tour dates. Its name, borrowed from a Soul Coughing lyric, also got it some very confused mail from members of the Nation of Islam.

The site grew out of an interview. In spring 1995 Moreschi interviewed Doughty by email for The Correspondent, the student paper at Capital Community-Technical College in Hartford, and the article ran that October. He later posted the full exchange and said the whole site started because of it, calling the article the 5% Nation's "magna carta." Doughty answered from a friend's computer in Nashville because his PowerBook was acting up, and in passing said the band really should set up a FAQ somewhere, since fans kept asking the same questions. The site's own update log starts on March 30, 1996. By late April its counter had passed 1,000 and Moreschi was asking readers to help propose a Usenet group and run a mailing list, and on July 13, 1996 Warner Bros. gave the site space on its own server.231

That same week a separate official site went up at soulcoughing.com, and Moreschi admitted in his update log that he was in awe of it, and a little afraid his page would get stomped out. It went the other way. By 1999 the 5% Nation was soulcoughing.com, with Moreschi as webmaster.34 Degli Antoni described the MP3 side of it on Green Room Tales, which was keen on the band's early embrace of the format. He said it began as an accident of having a website and a webmaster: Moreschi started posting a new MP3 each month, rarities and live tracks fans couldn't get anywhere else, meant to complement the albums rather than replace them. He believed it sent people to the record store, and said the band were online constantly, buying things, hunting for rarities and reprimanding people for selling their stuff.

Moreschi also ran contests. In one, fans filled in a blank from "Casiotone Nation": "The 5% Nation of ___." He got more than 200 entries and, with no bribes forthcoming, judged them on content. The ten winners included David Hasselhoff, Boutros Boutros-Ghali, Choco Tacos, ramen, Toby Huss (Artie on The Adventures of Pete & Pete, and a friend of Doughty's), Jagged Little Pill (its entrant calculated that 13 million copies sold came to an actual five percent of the country) and Angela Chase, a nod to tour manager Gus's famous crush on Claire Danes. "The 15% Nation of Organ Donor Waterslides" won too, on the theory that anybody who can enter a contest wrong must be doing something right.5

The master list: 204 more entries, as typed (spelling theirs)

The 5% Nation of… Female Bodybuilders! · Mount Rushmores · Fernando Valenzuela · Monday Night Football · hidely ho neighborino · Conan O' Brien · Clare Danes · armchair quarterbacks · America's Funniest Home Videos · Icey-Hot · 711 slurpies · lies · Electric Company · a thousand points of light · Handi-Snacks · Pinnochio · My Pet Monster · Kylie Menogue · the nightime, sniffeling, sneezing, coughing, aching, stuffyhead, fever so you can rest medicine · Grenwich mean time · iambic pentameter · soidum petathol · exponential growth · ready to asemble furnature · white beaded handbags · radient floor heating · freelance social workers · cubic zirconium · Marcel Duchamps · MTV buzz clips · man's deepest secret · Burnt Poptarts · Joannie Loves Chachie · unpasteurized fruit juice · Fat Free Cheese Spread · Bone Thugz and Harmony · Budakon · Minoxidil · Tagament HB · Spamburgers · vegan pork chops · plastic mary's · neon lights · trickle-down economics · five grams of fat · five percent tax increase · Las Vegas, Nevada · drunk balerinas · pushpops · corn on the cob · utter happiness · Bo Bradys · Pez Collectors · Maytag Repair Men! · Slickery Throat Drops · Psychic Friends Network · Masticated Fruit Roll-Ups · Ostrich Farmers · Free Indirect Discourse · Almond Joy · coffee grounds · Opus · frito lay · gel electrophoresis · Dan Santat · Spinal Tap · Jabba the Hutt · William Shatner · Mrs. Butterworth · left handed NUN CHUCKS · women's shoes · fossil fuel · teacher strikes · Radio Shack · Ben Gay · adjustable cheese slicers · modern idolatry · neon green fuzzy dice · "What's in the city water?" · mine is bigger than yours · Dick and Jane · yogart covered pretzels · "Honey, I shrunk the kids" · popcorn flavoured gourmet jelly beans · "I'm trying to win this contest to impress this woman I love!" · godlike trainman · Corinthian leather · free car wash · leggo my Eggo · Ricki Lake · mutual funds · salary caps · Kevin Bacon · butane BBQs · Hard Copy · page under construction · chardonnay · kotter · shoots and ladders · honk if you love · opus nightlights · swamp coolers · Albertsons A+ root beer · mini blinds · nordictrack · Molsen Ice beer · hip huggers · bell bottoms · speedos · Canon bubblejets · UPS · Calamari · Chimichaungas · Girbauds · Bill Clinton · carbohydrates · Marlboro · pewter Elvis statuettes · Overworked Middle Management · Downsizing and Outsourcing · Synergetic Mergers · Vertical Market Strategies · Ludwig Wittgenstein · Soccer Moms · Coolmint Toothpaste · Hare Krishna · Ingmar Bergman · Who Shot Tupac? · Bluelight special · coup de'tat! coup de'tat! · Plastic Toothpicks · Dennis Rodman · rabid chipmunks · Al-uh-Min-yum [aluminum] · Doctored JPEGs · Pita Bread · Golden oldies · Mr. Pibb · Cinnamin Pop Tarts · Funkdafied Blacklight · Strawberry Dacquiri · glow-in-the-dark · fire hydrants · Tang · Xena, Warrior Princess · Atari · snuphaluphagus · yahoo serious · coocoo for cocoa puffs · golf digest · fundip · bithchin camero's · tito santana · corki thatcher · wedgies in gym class · Matt Corcoran · B.A. Barracus · Cloud City · free cheese · Optimus Prime · Juan Epstein · frozen custard · bottled beer · the 20 piece bucket · Pro Wings · Bedtime for Bonzo · Kip Winger · tube socks · Gershon Mosley · Fat guys in Flannel · scott-O kelley · rusty the bailiff · Centeral Perk · Burt Reynolds · ramen noodles · lame contests that make you pay for shipping · Molly Ringwald · KFC · anti-lock brakes · Carmen Electra · Winnie the Pooh · House of Style · Latter-Day Saints · Sesame Street · SuperAmerica · Walt Disney · Jean-Luc Picard · White Castle Hamburgers · Saved By The BELL · Hasselhoff · "Hey it's George Kennedy!" · Jagged Little Pill · 2% Milk · (the 15% Nation of) Organ Donor Waterslides · Boutros Boutros Ghali · Going and Going and Going · Strawberry Quick · "everywhere you want to be" · Choco-Tacos · angela chase · Toby Huss · Chili Dogs · Jesus Night Lights · Pat Sajak

The regulars became part of the site too. Anne Marie Kwasnik turns up all over the 1996 logs: catching a wrong tour date, chasing down a magazine that had misplaced its Soul Coughing story, winning a contest slot with Toby Huss, and complaining when updates were slow, until Moreschi posted one addressed to her by name. The official site later ran a photo of her car, a burgundy Miata with New York plates that read SOLCOUGH.3

Rear of a burgundy Miata convertible with a New York license plate reading SOLCOUGH
Anne Marie's Miata, as seen on the band's official site. Fandom, 1990s edition.

Opus Moreschi was the 5% Nation's "benevolent ruler," as one newsgroup regular put it, and one of the earliest people building Soul Coughing pages anywhere. Before alt.music.soulcoughing even existed, he was posting as "opusmo" in the They Might Be Giants newsgroup, which is where Soul Coughing fans hung out in 1996. The site ran the store page that sold Slanky by mail, plus news, lyrics and song notes, and Mat Leffler-Schulman's FAQ sent people there for lyrics. Regulars said it had "just about everything," and the standard sign-off when quoting it was "much props to Opus."1

Moreschi went on to a career in comedy. After writing and performing at iO West and the Upright Citizens Brigade, he joined The Colbert Report, became its head writer, and followed Stephen Colbert to The Late Show, where he rose to supervising producer and, in 2020, co-executive producer. He has won Emmys for writing on both shows, including Outstanding Writing for a Variety Series as Colbert Report head writer in 2014, plus Writers Guild Awards and a share of a Peabody.

SCUG

SCUG, short for Soul Coughing Underground, has been the band's unofficial home on the web since the mid-1990s. Ythan Burstein started it as a fully independent fan site, then handed it to Mat in 1996 so he could go start a magic mushroom farm. Mat swears this is true. (The newsgroup didn't hear about the handover until May 1997, when a regular posted "Props to Ythan (of SCUG)" and told everyone to say hi to the new guy.)1

Soul Coughing Underground logo
The old SCUG logo.

By late 1996 Warner Bros. had offered to host the site and send over promo goodies, so SCUG moved onto Warner's own servers at wbr.com/soulcough, one directory over from the 5% Nation, which was already linking there in October 1996.3 That got Mat closer to the band, and they started handing him stuff directly because it was easier than going through the label. So by the end of the band's first run SCUG had a second job: it was how the band got things to fans without the label in the middle. Quietly underground, on a major label's server. The name turned out to be pretty accurate.

The 5% Nation had most of the band's writings and lyrics first. SCUG's own thing was a little different:

  • The gigography. Every show we could pin down, which is the backbone of the Shows page on this site.
  • The message boards. SCUG's board opened in 1997 when fans fled Warner's word filter (the one that wouldn't let you type "accumulate"), and in early 2000 it hosted an official board where degli Antoni and Gabay posted.
  • Interviews and chats you couldn't get anywhere else. Jessica "Feetnik" Dungan's November 1999 email interview with degli Antoni, degli Antoni's two-and-a-half-hour fan chat on March 3, 2000 (where he explained why he backed Liquid Audio over MP3 and called one of the August 1999 9:30 Club nights the band's best recent show), and Andy's interview with him, which SMASH Magazine also ran.6
  • Stuff the band handed over. Liquid Audio rarities, a Mixman "Circles" remix kit, the El Oso cartoons, a 1995 Bugle Boy ad, a Dutch TV set with "Buddha Rhubarb Butter" sung alongside the a cappella group the Prodigal Songs, and Soul Coughing Radio, a 24-hour stream built with degli Antoni and Jon Gilmour.
  • The FAQ. Birthdays, the bears, the crew, and the taping rules: audio only, bring your own gear, email the band ahead so they can find you a dry spot, and send copies to the band and SCUG. Plus a tab archive, a CD finder and a tape-trading page.
  • News, from the breakup on through the 2010s, including the first word of the Kufala live series in January 2003.7

After sorting out the domain with Warner, the site moved to scug.net on December 20, 2000.

In May 2000 he announced his own graduation on the news page, Donna-from-90210 style: MAT GRADUATES, MAT GRADUATES! Then he went on to work in TV at the Discovery Channel and in radio at DC101, produced records at Mobtown Studios, and is now a Grammy-nominated mastering engineer. He's still running SCUG (web master deluxe, emeritus). This page is a group project. Got a tape, a set list, a photo or a correction? Send it in: hello@scug.net. Mucho thanks.

The Old About Page

Here's how SCUG introduced itself back in the day, straight from the old About page:

Hi there! Welcome to SCUG, "The page about Soul Coughing" [trademark pending.] Mat is your host, waiter and web master deluxe. For anyone out there unfamiliar or vaguely familiar with the said band, take a look around and see what Soul Coughing can do for you. For all of you big crazy Soul Coughing fans out there who know what it's all about, we are pretty sure you'll find this page to be an excellent repository (not to be confused with suppository) of information on the said band. Take a look around and see what SCUG can do for you. Oh yeah, we almost forgot: Enjoy the page!

Handwritten note signed by Mark degli Antoni, M. Doughty, Sebastian Steinberg and Yuval Gabay
An undated note signed by all four, in what looks like Mark's handwriting. They regret being unable to paint a funny animal. If you know the story behind it, write in.

See it the way it looked in 1999, green background, thank-you list and all. SCUG was always a group project, and that page thanks everybody who kept it going.

A few of the names on that thank-you list, as the newsgroup remembers them:1

  • J-Dude was the group's town crier in 1997. He spread the word about the HBO Reverb broadcast, steered people to SCUG's new board after Warner folded the old Lounge into its own message boards ("NOT cool. Don't waste your time"), flagged CMJ's story on Gus Brandt rolling with the Foo Fighters, and on Christmas Day 1997 announced Slanky-⁠L, the new and "more importantly, RELIABLE" mailing list.1
  • Jon Gilmour, posting as JOnnyRotten, set up an unofficial Soul Coughing chat server in July 1999, where regulars played rounds of "truth or truth," and later built Soul Coughing Radio with degli Antoni.1
  • March Hare was one of the busiest voices in the Candybar from the end of 1999 well into 2002, long after the band itself had split.1
  • Kim Long posted from 1997 through 2000 and was part of the Candybar crew that met up at shows.1

The Newsgroup, the Mailing List and the AOL Board

Three other gathering places ran alongside the websites, and one of them survives almost complete. The Usenet group alt.music.soulcoughing logged its first posts in December 1996 and, by the time it went quiet in 2013, held roughly 3,050 threads and 12,700 posts, now readable through UsenetArchives.com. Traffic tells the band's story on its own: a few dozen posts a month through 1997, a jump to 151 in September 1998 as El Oso arrived, a peak of 678 in February 1999, hundreds a month through the last tours, then a steep falloff after the March 2000 announcement. Early regulars complained that nobody posted and spammers outnumbered fans; by 1999 the group had become a social club in its own right, with long off-topic threads, regional meetups at shows and a FAQ of in-jokes, and newcomers asking where the band talk had gone. It was also a clearinghouse: tape-trade lists, set lists posted from memory, tour dates copied from fan sites and radio, and the stunned threads of March 2000.1

The AOL board came first. Fans found it under the keyword MMC, and the band posted there directly; Doughty's El Oso Novella (posted as "The Making of El Oso"), "Disclaimer of Luv" and "Peach Pit Babylon" all appeared on it first, and in Dispatch #4 he name-checked "our AOL folder" as the place the Amsterdam radio bootleg circulated. He kept up with it on the road, too. In a Rolling Stone Online roundup of musicians' computers in fall 1996, he said he checked the Soul Coughing folder on the AOL music boards and posted band updates, adding that "the fans know more than I do." He had given up his phone and apartment before that tour, so his PowerBook and e-mail were his line to the outside world, and he bought a new PowerBook every two years and wore each one out.8 A fan from the AOL board wrote a show newsletter called Candybar that was handed out at 1997 gigs. The band's official site had its own Lounge bulletin board until Warner folded it into the label's message boards in June 1997 with a word filter so strict it blocked "accumulate," from the lyrics of "Collapse"; fans moved to SCUG's new board in protest. By 1999 Doughty had a message board of his own, and later superspecialquestions.com and its fan BBS.910111213

The mailing list arrived on Christmas Day 1997. Slanky-⁠L, named for Doughty's poetry book and run independently by a fan off a Binghamton University server, replaced an earlier list called Softserve that had stopped working, and its subscription notice was reposted to the newsgroup every few weeks into 2000. The book itself was sold by mail through the 5% Nation: about 50 poems, $12.98 by check to Soul Coughing Touring Inc., which had sold out its previous printing in two shows. The 5% Nation, run by Opus Moreschi, sat on Warner's server at wbr.com/soulcoughing, one directory over from SCUG at wbr.com/soulcough. A March 1997 post listed them with soulcoughing.com as the three main sites; by mid-1997 regulars were calling SCUG the most frequently updated of the three. Sadly, neither the Slanky-⁠L archives nor the AOL board survived.1

After the split, the newsgroup kept a thinner pulse. "Mike Doughty HQ" posted his tour dates there, including a fall 2002 college tour opening for Rusted Root and August 2003 club dates in Hoboken, Brooklyn and Philadelphia, and the first word of the Kufala live releases reached the group on January 17, 2003.17

By 1999 the regulars had their own name for the group, "the Candybar," after the "candy bar" chants in "Super Bon Bon" and a Doughty line about words burning the air "like the names of candy bars." When Doughty chanted "Candybar! Candybar!" from the stage in Las Vegas in February 1999, posters wondered whether he'd been reading. They met up at shows, mailed each other burned CDs of the 9:30 Club broadcast, ran an internet station called Soul Coughing Radio in 2000, and the first weekend of November 2000 a carload of them rode up to New York with Mat from SCUG to see UV Ray, Gabay and Steinberg's drum and bass project ("awesome awesome band," one of them reported back).1 After the split the group thinned out ("It's like a ghost town in here," one wrote that April) as people moved to Doughty's superspecialquestions.com board.

The tape-trading culture the band encouraged lives on in the Internet Archive's Soul Coughing collection in its Live Music Archive. Recent additions include soundboard cassette transfers credited to Mat Leffler-Schulman, such as the December 17, 1993 CB's 313 Gallery show. The Hello CD of the Month Club EP is also archived there.

A Secret Club With No Bouncer

Being a Soul Coughing fan in the 1990s felt like belonging to a secret club that never quite agreed on who the members were. You'd spot a stranger in a Ruby Vroom shirt and the conversation was already underway. Tapes got mailed across the country, set lists got passed around, and half the vocabulary (the Candybar, Slowdog, the bears) made sense only to people who had been paying attention. It was close to family, with the in-jokes, the stories everybody had heard before and the arguments about who owned the better tape that come with one.

The band started it. Doughty wrote in the 1994 tour diary that standing around an airport, it was dawning on them that the band was turning into a kind of family, and the door stayed open from there: fan email answered from the road, posts on the AOL board, a taping policy friendlier than most bands would dare. Fans took the hint. Regulars met up at shows, mailed each other burned CDs, and in November 2000 a carload of them rode up to New York with Mat to see UV Ray. One fan, Sharla Smith, ended up designing a band 7-inch sleeve and posing with the band for it.

For all that insider feeling, nobody got quizzed at the door. The crowds were a mix from the start (Doughty noted hip-hop kids in Atlanta, indie rock types in Cleveland and Minneapolis, bespectacled hipsters in Chicago), and nobody had to pick a lane. The newsgroup argued loudly about everything, including whether El Oso was bland or the tightest the rhythm section ever sounded, and both sides stayed in the same group. Day-one fan or someone who heard "Circles" last Tuesday, the answer to "do I belong here?" was the same. The only bouncers anyone worried about worked at the clubs, and they were why the taping rules existed.1

When the 2024 reunion shows sold out in hours, it turned out the community had never really gone away. The newsgroup threads, the Candybar meetups, the archived set lists, the burned CDs of the 9:30 Club broadcast: all of it had spent 24 years waiting for word. It came. So did they.1

If you're new here, consider this your invitation. There's no secret handshake (we never settled on one). Come on in, and if you have a tape, a photo or a story, write in.


  1. alt.music.soulcoughing newsgroup, 1996 to 2013, via UsenetArchives.com. ↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎

  2. Opus Moreschi, email interview with M. Doughty, spring 1995, for "The Original Alterna-Hip-Hop-Jazz-Rock-Funk-Indie-Dada-Beat Poetry Group," The Correspondent (Capital Community-Technical College), vol. 12 no. 1, October 1995; full answers posted on The 5% Nation. ↩︎↩︎

  3. "News" and "What's New," The 5% Nation, March to October 1996, via the Wayback Machine. ↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎

  4. "The News," The 5% Nation (soulcoughing.com), July 1999 to March 2000, via the Wayback Machine. ↩︎

  5. "The Winners!," contest results, The 5% Nation, via the Wayback Machine. ↩︎

  6. Jessica Dungan, interview with Mark degli Antoni, SCUG, November 1999. ↩︎

  7. Kufala Recordings announcement, January 2003, and Brady's newsgroup post, February 20, 2003. ↩︎↩︎

  8. Mary Huhn, "Alt.rock," Rolling Stone Online, Technology section, fall 1996. ↩︎

  9. M. Doughty, "The Making of El Oso," AOL music board, December 1, 1997. ↩︎

  10. Rolling Stone. ↩︎

  11. M. Doughty, tour Dispatches #1 to #4, AOL, November 1994 to February 1995. ↩︎

  12. M. Doughty, "Disclaimer of Luv," AOL. ↩︎

  13. M. Doughty, "Peach Pit Babylon," AOL, 1995 to 1996. ↩︎

Search

Every show, song, record and chapter. Try a venue, a city, a song, a year, a name or your zodiac sign.